Buying Guide

Selling Your Mercedes CLA-Class? Here Are The 5 Best Alternatives To Buy

The Mercedes CLA is the king of compact coupés, but stylish rivals are everywhere. We explore the top 5 alternatives, from the BMW 2 Series Gran Coupé to the high-performance Audi RS 3 Saloon.

The Apany Team

Published on 13 September 2025

7 min read

Selling Your Mercedes CLA-Class? Here Are The 5 Best Alternatives To Buy

The second-generation Mercedes CLA (C118, 2019-present) cemented its position as the default choice for a premium compact four-door coupé. With its swooping roofline, frameless doors, and stunning MBUX dual-screen interior, especially in popular AMG Line trims like the CLA 180 and CLA 200, it offers a junior CLS experience. But the competition is fierce. If you're selling and want a change, here are five detailed alternatives that challenge the CLA's dominance.

1. BMW 2 Series Gran Coupé (F44)

The CLA's direct rival, the BMW 2 Series Gran Coupé (2019-present) offers a different philosophy. While the CLA is soft and curvaceous, the BMW is taut and angular. It's based on the same front-wheel-drive platform as the 1 Series, but BMW's engineers have worked magic to ensure it feels agile and engaging to drive, particularly in M Sport trim. The cabin is solidly built and driver-focused, though less flashy than the CLA's.

Key Features & Variants

Core Models: The 218i uses a punchy 1.5-litre three-cylinder engine, while the 220d offers superb long-distance economy from its 2.0-litre diesel.
Performance Hero: The M235i xDrive model features a 306 hp 2.0-litre turbo engine and all-wheel drive, making it a direct competitor to the Mercedes-AMG CLA 35.
Driving Dynamics: Features ARB technology (actuator contiguous wheel slip limitation) from the i3s, which improves traction and reduces understeer for a sharper drive.

2. Audi A3 & RS 3 Saloon (8Y)

Where the CLA shouts about its style, the Audi A3 Saloon (2020-present) speaks with quiet confidence. Its design is a masterpiece of sharp creases and perfect proportions, appearing more mature than its rivals. The interior is its strongest suit, with flawless build quality and the fantastic Virtual Cockpit Plus digital display. It's a supremely refined and comfortable cruiser, especially in S line trim.

For the ultimate performance, the Audi RS 3 Saloon's 2.5-litre five-cylinder engine and trick rear differential offer a character and capability that even the AMG CLA 45 S struggles to match.

Key Takeaway

The A3 Saloon family is the choice for those who value sophisticated technology and understated design, with a performance ceiling that is second to none in the class.

3. Peugeot 508 Fastback (Gen 2)

For a true style statement outside the German establishment, the Peugeot 508 (2018-present, facelifted 2023) is a superb choice. It’s slightly larger than the CLA, but its avant-garde fastback design is stunning. The 2023 facelift added a frameless grille and new claw-effect lights. Inside, the i-Cockpit with its small steering wheel and high-set digital dials feels futuristic and special, especially in GT trim.

Checklist for the Design-Conscious

Potent Powertrains: The HYBRID 225 model offers a great blend of performance and efficiency, while the top-tier Peugeot Sport Engineered (PSE) version is a 360 hp, all-wheel-drive performance hybrid.
Practical Style: The fastback tailgate is much more practical than a traditional boot lid for loading bulky items.
French Flair: Offers a unique and comfortable ride quality that differs from the firm sportiness of its German rivals.

4. Mazda 3 Saloon (Gen 4)

The fourth-generation Mazda 3 Saloon (2019-present) is a hidden gem that delivers a truly premium experience. Its minimalist 'Kodo' design is beautiful, and the cabin quality is exceptional for the price, with soft-touch materials and elegant switchgear that feel genuinely upmarket. Models like the GT Sport Tech are packed with equipment that is often an expensive option on the CLA.

Standout Features

Premium-Level Cabin: The fit, finish, and ergonomic focus can genuinely rival cars from the class above.
Innovative Engine: The 186ps 2.0-litre e-Skyactiv X engine uses Spark Controlled Compression Ignition (SPCCI) to offer the efficiency of a diesel with the free-revving nature of a petrol.
Value for Money: Offers a very high level of standard specification for a competitive price.

5. Hyundai i30 Fastback N (Facelift)

If you were drawn to the performance of an AMG CLA 35, the facelifted Hyundai i30 Fastback N (2021-present) is a must-consider alternative. It’s a pure-bred performance car that prioritises driver engagement above all else. Its 2.0-litre T-GDi engine produces 280 PS and sounds incredible. It may lack the premium badge, but for raw thrills, its combination of an e-LSD, adaptive suspension, and powerful brakes is hard to beat for the money.

Why Choose the i30 Fastback N?

Thrilling Performance: The N DCT gearbox offers an 'N Grin Shift' overboost button for 20 seconds of maximum attack.
Adjustability: The N Grin Control System allows you to customise the engine, steering, suspension, and exhaust note to your liking.
Style and Substance: Combines its incredible performance with a sleek and practical fastback body shape.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main competitor to the Mercedes CLA (C118)?

The main competitor to the Mercedes CLA (C118 generation) is the BMW 2 Series Gran Coupé (F44). Both are premium four-door coupés based on their respective brand's entry-level hatchback. The CLA is often seen as more stylish with a more luxurious interior, especially in AMG Line trim, while the 2 Series Gran Coupé, particularly in M Sport guise, offers a slightly sharper driving experience.

Which CLA alternative has the best interior technology?

While the CLA's MBUX system is excellent, the Audi A3 Saloon (8Y generation) is a strong contender for the best tech-focused interior. Its combination of the Audi Virtual Cockpit digital instrument cluster and the central MMI Touch display is incredibly slick, intuitive, and boasts impeccable build quality, especially in top-spec Vorsprung models.

What is a true high-performance alternative to the Mercedes-AMG CLA 45 S?

A direct high-performance rival to the Mercedes-AMG CLA 45 S is the Audi RS 3 Saloon. The latest 8Y generation features a legendary 2.5-litre five-cylinder turbocharged engine producing 400 PS (395 hp) and includes an innovative RS Torque Splitter on the rear axle, allowing for controlled drifts and incredible cornering agility.

“Most people aren’t aware that consignment, where a dealer sells your car for you, is even an option. It's the hassle-free way to get the best price without the risks of a private sale.”

Sell Your Mercedes CLA-Class on Consignment with Apany

Ready to switch from your stylish CLA to a new head-turner? Apany connects you with trusted UK dealers who will sell your Mercedes CLA for the best possible price, avoiding the low offers of a trade-in.

Simply list your car and let our network of vetted professionals handle the entire sales process. It's the smart, hassle-free way to sell your car. Start your consignment journey here with Apany.

The Apany Team

Apany Team